If Technology Is Effective in the Classroom – Why Do Some Students Dislike It So Much?


The effectiveness of technology use within the school room has come to be a controversial issue. While many instructors and students feel that it’s fine to use generation to complement teaching, many others experience that it reasons too many challenges and wastes time. If technology is as effective in the classroom as many instructors trust it, why do little college students dislike it so much?

To objectively reply to this question, 3 articles were examined. 2 out of the three relate how the usage of generation within the classroom frustrates students. The last one interprets the mind of college students who feel that technology within the lecture room has answered their needs. So the issue isn’t that generation is not powerful but alternatively that some instructors want to be mindful of technology use within the school room and others want to be taught to properly use technology to train so that scholars do no longer view era as obstruction getting to know but as an improvement tool.


Let us first summarize the articles that we’re relating to. After summarizing the three articles that have been reviewed, we will be able to show that there are 2 organizations of college students who declare to dislike generation within the schoolroom: Those who’re improperly uncovered to it using their trainer and people who did no longer supply themselves enough time to familiarize themselves with it. We will then be able to conclude that identical students could respect the fee of the era in the classroom if their instructors used it properly.


The article “When accurate era way terrible coaching associated that many college students feel that instructors and professors use technology as a way to show off. Students complain of era making their teachers “much less powerful than they might be if they stuck to a lecture on the chalkboard” (Young) different troubles associated through students encompass instructors losing magnificence time to teach about a web tool or to flab with a projector or software program. When teachers are unexpected with the technological tools, they may probably be wasting extra time looking to use them; the technological software program used the most with college students is PowerPoint. Students bitch that instructors use it in preference to their lesson plan. Many students explain that it makes know-how tougher, “I name it PowerPoint abuse” (Young). Professors also publish their PowerPoint Presentations to the school board before and after elegance, which encourages college students to miss more lessons.

Another problem pronounced inside the article with the use of generation inside the school rooms is that many schools spend time training their workers on how to use a selected generation. Still, it does not train them on “techniques to apply them properly” (Young). The writer believed that faculties should also supply small economic incentives to teachers and professors to attend workshops.

In an interview made with thirteen college students, “some gave their teacher a failing whilst it got here to using PowerPoint, Course Management structures and other study room generation” (Young ) a number of the complaints had been again approximately the misuse of PowerPoint’s and the reality that instructors use it to recite what’s on the scale. Another complaint turned into those unexpected instructors who often waste class time as they spend more time troubleshooting than coaching. The final bitch referred to is that some instructors require students to comment on online chat rooms weekly but no longer screen the outcome or connect with the discussion in elegance.

Similarly, the item “I’m now not a laptop person” (Lohnes 2013) speaks to the fact that students’ expectancies as ways as the era is worried could be unique. In a take a look at executed with 34 undergraduate college students, they advise that era is a necessary part of a college students existence due to the fact they ought to do need to everything online from making use of for university or college, looking and registering for lessons, pay lessons and that further to being incorporated inside the administration, etc. Generation is likewise extensively used to teach and is valued via better training.

Those college students, but, feel that era poses a barrier to fulfillment as they warfare to align with how the institution values era.” A scholar explains that technology is utilized in her freshman year to show in assignments, participate in discussion boards and blogs, email the professor, view grades, and for an extensive range of other administrative missions, including tracking the subsequent faculty bus. This precise scholar, whose call is Nichole, says that she does not own a PC but stocks a family computer. She has a younger brother who additionally uses the computer to finish his faculty paintings, so she has to live up past due to finish assignments. She states, “era and I? We by no means had that connection” (Lohnes). Nichole dislikes the truth that her college requests that she have greater touch with technology than she is comfortable with. Nonetheless, she explains that as she commenced doing the one’s college online assignments so regularly, she got here to recognize that they had been no longer that bad.

One of her issues, even with the era, is that she had come from Puerto Rico about a year before entering university and that she never needed to use the computer so much there. The article relates that different college students like Nichole have admitted: “reluctant technology customers” (Lohnes). The article wants to explain, in essence, that although most people could assume that university students choose technology and are already familiar with it,” that assumption is faulty” (Lohnes).

On the opposite hand, the thing “What Screenagers Say About… ” High school-age college students have been requested about what they thought of technology; however, maximum expressed liking it. One of them said approximately PowerPoint: “My records instructor did an amazing task with PowerPoints. He could put them online, which made for simply remarkable critiques.” (Screneagers, 2011) Others expressed how era became actually who they’re and that teachers have to understand that when they textual content in class, they’re no longer impolite; however, they have gotten used to multi-tasking. Another scholar invitations instructors to no longer are scared of a generation “Teachers should not be frightened of generation. Understand that it is how we stay our lives. So do not just push it out. Learn to cope with us and the way we work.” (Screenagers, 2011)

Another scholar expressed how she prefers less difficult technology that her teacher is cozy with instead of high tech that the teacher no longer controls well. “The maximum essential thing for teachers is to be comfortable with what they’re the usage of. It mustn’t be super high-tech. My math trainer used a projector, and it changed into one of my preferred classes. Then I could visit this other class in which the trainer used PowerPoints and the SMARTboard. However, I did not get any greater out of it due to the fact she wasn’t comfy with the generation” (Screenagers, 2011). Students spoke about their appreciation for actually all sorts of generations used inside the study room. Another said, “One of my instructors used Skype. That’s face-to-face interplay. If I had trouble with a few math hassles I become operating on; I should take a picture of it and put it on the Skype display screen. She should see where I turned into making my mistake. It sincerely helped.” (Screenagers, 2011) The backside line is that excessive college students wanted to let instructors realize that they really like generation and that it’s far already a exquisite part of their daily routine. However, it needed to be used well for them to enjoy it.

Similarly, they summarize some matters that they dislike as well. Among the list, they stated: reading at the laptop, paying lots for an online textbook, and they often forget about the whole lot else when they get stuck up with the usage of generation.

Nonetheless, they had an awful lot of extra advantageous things they preferred in an era like, for example, some instructors would text content a query for them to think about earlier than magnificence. If they do not understand the solution, they might talk with classmates to discuss the possibility of the solution before elegance. This allows them to go to elegant organized. They also like using Skype, emailing their teachers instead of going to talk to them in person. They also revel in dialogue boards. The recommendation they would like to deliver to their teachers is to ensure that they are comfy with anything technological gear they are using, to offer them extra freedom to use the good websites and those in the middle variety when they are browsing the net using school computer systems and to remember that technology is part of their lives.

After summarizing the articles, we will see that the scholars noted in Youngs, 2004 dislike technology because their experience has become no longer first-rate. In different terms, a set of students dislike generation because some teachers are not mindful of generation use or need additional schooling. For instance, some students are frustrated because they experience that teachers waste their time while they are no longer properly skilled to use the technological gear. Others disliked the reality that some teachers had PowerPoint presentations that have been either not significant or they might just read anything they wrote and upload no additional comments. Those examples are referred to as “bad teaching (Young, 2004), and they’re, in fact, horrible examples that instructors have to observe no longer because the era is not supposed to help teachers do the least work or to adopt poor teaching practices. Some college students associated that PowerPoint turned into broadly used by instructors even to name it PowerPoint abuse.


I can relate to what’s being expressed via those students. I discovered a Teaching Assistant teaches a grammar class these days. He bought a device to allow him to reveal the display without touching the PC. He became in a position to walk for the duration of the magnificence simultaneously as converting slides. It all seemed so staggering; however, college students have been left so confused at the end of the lesson despite all of this show. When they requested questions, he went back to the grammar rule slide and studied it over to the elegance. The PowerPoint was a duplication of the textbook chapter. The equal examples of the e-book were used. At the end of the direction, he felt that he had achieved an excellent PowerPoint whilst, in fact, it became not significant. It changed into a replica/paste project from the text e-book to the display screen. This instance indicates that we want to apply commonplace feel whilst the use of generation. When coaching grammar, an instructor will come up with examples apart from the ones in the e-book. You have to write on the board, have students exercise what they have got found out. PowerPoint use became a actual awful idea, in my view, for teaching this direction. It has become just now not the right technological device for the lesson.

Students in that magnificence may additionally determine that they hate Power Points because it confuses them greater while the issue isn’t with the usage of PowerPoint but as an alternative with the teacher’s bad preference of generation. The point I additionally need to make right here is that teachers can also, from time to time, be ignorant of their incorrect use of generation. This is why, as educators, we often want to ask students for their feedback so we may additionally make corrections where wished.

There isn’t any indication that the one’s college students dislike the use of generation. We can then conclude that those college students dislike generation due to fallacious technological use by instructors. Additionally, many teachers no longer attend workshops or training sessions to help them attain broader information of era because they’re so busy. Like endorse (Youngs, 2004) and (Lohnes, 2012), those identical busy instructors could have attended those training if there had been given an incentive. The object “Technology Standards in a Third-Grade Classroom” (Kovalik, 2001) is associated with how a study accomplished in a 3rd grade class of 25 showed that scholars were properly using generation. The article also referred to how the teachers had been rather skilled because the Ohio board pays incentives to teachers to take part in generation education, which teaches them how to use era through teaching them strategies to apply them.

Boards from other states need to bear in mind doing the equal aspect to ensure that their teachers are responding to the technological need of their students and that they may be teaching them in step with the requirements. The Ohio college referred to above met the requirements as far as generation is concerned because of the generation coaching acquired by lecturers. If instructors learn the way to use technology within the lecture room correctly, it will be a much less frustrating enjoy for them and for the student who will less possibly dislike technology on account that it’s going to meet its cause to enhance coaching.

The other students who dislike technology are folks who were no longer uncovered to it for long enough. The College Freshman, Nichole advises that she changed into no longer exposed to a lot of technology while she became in excessive faculty in her domestic us of a; consequently, it seemed to be a burden to her to need a laptop to complete a maximum of her faculty assignments however also to interact along with her classmate thru a dialogue board. What is thrilling, although, is that even though she claimed to dislike the era so much, she cautioned that when she commenced spending so much time using it, she realizes that it is not so awful. Even though it’s far in all likelihood that some humans do now, not just like the cellphone and texting a lot, the laptop and a few internet sites have become a part of the majority day by day habitual. In Nichole’s case, she no longer owns a PC and has to await her flip to apply the circle of relatives’ computer. Because of this, she has no attachment to this media because her use of it’s far controlled. However, once she receives too very own her own PC, it is assured that her view of technology will exchange.

I back to high school after about 12 years. When I was in college the first time around, nothing was digital; however, once I contacted USF to apply, they told me that the entirety was online. At first, I asked why the entirety became online, but as soon as I was used to it, I started to understand the fee of having the convenience to do many factors without having to live my home.

Therefore, Nichole will truly not maintain to dislike the era that tons as soon as she gets more familiar and extra connected to it. The truth is that she stated that she began to realize that it changed into now not that terrible once she commenced doing so many assignments. She concluded that the PC turned into not yet a friend but that it became no longer an enemy; it became an acquaintance to her.

With this know-how, relying on the historical past of some ELL students and depending on whether or not or not they were exposed to the generation of their home use, they will not like generation at the start, but this needs not to be a signal that they’ll never come to like it. As trainers, we can allow them time to familiarize themselves with it whilst we use it properly. We do not advise against it, or involuntary ship ignored records approximately its genuine fee.

On the alternative hand, the ultimate article testifies to the fact that the new technology is era driven and that after being used nicely, they benefit from it inside the schoolroom; there are several examples of how instructors at the start used generation to train that is liked by way of students. What must the conclusion be then?

We have confirmed that era use is powerful inside the classroom but that instructors need to take some actions to make this device beneficial to college students. They must acquire some schooling if they lack it and prefer a scholar recommended in the Screenager article; they must refrain from using complicated gear if they’re not sure approximately how to use them. It’s great to correctly use something a whole lot less complicated than they’re acquainted with, like a high school scholar recommended.

In addition, it’s far crucial for instructors to display screen the limitless technological gear and investigate them before introducing them to their teaching. Should they test some that don’t make paintings properly, they have to forestall using them and seek extra suitable ones. Most importantly, the era isn’t always continually the solution. This is why instructors ought to be balanced whilst the usage of it. If it’s miles required that we use the board and chalks to assist students higher apprehend, that is what we need to do. By doing so, we can make sure that more college students appreciate the usage of generation in the study room for what it’s miles really worth.

Work Cited

Kovalik, Cindy, Lynn Smolen, and Jazmine Toddy. “Technology Standards In A Third-Grade Classroom.” Journal Of Research On Computing In Education 33.Five (2001): 1-17. Academic Search Premier. Web. Nine Aug. 2013 Lohnes Watulak, Sarah. “‘I’m Not a Computer Person’: Negotiating Participation in Academic Discourses.” British Journal Of Educational Technology 43.1(2012):109-118. OmniFile Full-Text Mega (H.W.Wilson). Web.9Aug. 2013. Young, Jeffrey R. “When Good Technology Means Bad Teaching” Chronicle Of Higher Education fifty-one.12(2004): A31-A31. Academic Search Premier. Web.9Aug.2013. What Screenagers Say About… (2011). Educational Leadership, 68(five), forty four-46 Wed. Nine Aug.2013. By NICK MYRCA MALEBRANCHE- GAUTHIER